Hi,
Most people assume a major career reset means throwing away everything you have done and starting from scratch.
In reality, the skills you pick up during an unexpected detour often carry you further than your original plan ever could.
On Saturday, December 12, our ExperienceTO: Queen Street West Historical Tour begins on the front steps of Campbell House, a red-brick Georgian mansion at the northwest corner of Queen Street West and University Avenue. Built in 1822, it is the oldest surviving building from the original Town of York (the small settlement that grew into modern-day Toronto).
Looking at its quiet brick exterior today, it is easy to assume the man who built it lived a smooth, predictable life. The opposite was true.
William Campbell was born in northern Scotland in 1758. He briefly studied law as a teenager until his instructor died, cutting his schooling short. With few prospects at home, he joined a British Highland regiment and crossed the Atlantic to fight in the American Revolutionary War.
That decision landed him in a prison camp. In 1781, British forces surrendered at Yorktown, Virginia, and Campbell was captured as a prisoner of war.
Two years later, the Treaty of Paris was signed in 1783, officially ending the war. Britain recognized the independence of its Thirteen Colonies along the Atlantic coast, including places like New York, Massachusetts, and Virginia, which joined together to form the new United States.
That outcome left tens of thousands of people stranded on the losing side. British regiments were disbanded, and American colonists who had stayed loyal to the British Crown, known as Loyalists, often faced hostility and the loss of their property in the new republic. To resettle them, the British government offered free land grants in its remaining northern territories, which eventually became Canada.
In 1784, Campbell arrived with a group of these refugees at Chedabucto Bay on the eastern coast of Nova Scotia, making a new home in a remote fishing village called Guysborough.
Life on the frontier was bleak, and Campbell struggled to make a living. Seeing his neighbour’s frustration, a local resident named Thomas Cutler suggested Campbell return to his abandoned legal studies. At the time, Nova Scotia had no formal law schools and a severe shortage of trained professionals. Aspiring lawyers qualified for the courts by reading legal texts and apprenticing under someone already familiar with the law.
Campbell studied alongside Cutler and began practising as an attorney around 1785. Because a small fishing village generated little legal work, he also ran a general store to pay the bills. That same year, he married Hannah Hadley, the daughter of an early Nova Scotia resident, and the two began raising what would become a family of six children.
Over the next two decades, Campbell took on whatever local work was available. He became a justice of the peace, won a seat in the Nova Scotia legislature, and eventually moved to neighbouring Cape Breton Island when the colonial government urgently needed an attorney general.
Then politics wiped out his progress. After clashing with Cape Breton’s administrator over government appointments and unpaid rent, Campbell was fired from his posts and locked out of his own house in July 1808. Just weeks shy of his fiftieth birthday, he was out of work and homeless.
Rather than giving up, Campbell sailed alone to London, England, to petition British officials for a new role. He spent more than two years away from Hannah and their children, lobbying the Colonial Office until they finally appointed him to a vacant seat on the Court of King's Bench in Upper Canada.
In November 1811, Campbell arrived in the Town of York to take his seat on the bench and bring his family over from Nova Scotia. He eventually rose to become Chief Justice of Upper Canada and the first judge in Upper Canada to be knighted.
In 1822, William and Hannah built their brick home on Duke Street (now Adelaide Street East) at the head of Frederick Street.
For 150 years, the house stood at that original site while Toronto grew up around it. Quiet residential lanes gave way to factories and warehouses. The former Chief Justice’s home was converted into business offices and later used as a factory that manufactured horseshoe nails.
By 1972, the property belonged to the Coutts-Hallmark Greeting Cards company, which wanted to tear the building down for a parking lot. They offered the house for free to anyone willing to pay to move it.
The Advocates' Society, an association of trial lawyers, stepped in to save the former Chief Justice’s residence. They raised the money, formed the Sir William Campbell Foundation, and coordinated a massive relocation. In the spring of 1972, city crews closed downtown streets while crowds watched the 270-tonne brick mansion slowly roll 1.6 kilometres to its current foundation at Queen and University.
Today, the City of Toronto owns the building and the land, handling major structural and exterior upkeep. Under an operating agreement with the city, the Sir William Campbell Foundation runs the property as a registered charity, keeping it open to the public as a museum, exhibition space, and community venue.
Campbell’s life shows that when going through a career reset, it's wise to carry what you already know into the next chapter.
He did not become Chief Justice through a single bold leap or sheer willpower. He reached it because every time a door slammed shut, whether in a Virginia prison camp, a quiet Nova Scotia fishing village, or a political fallout in Cape Breton, he took the practical skills he had already gathered and adapted them to whatever ground he landed on next.
When our own plans fall apart, we often assume we have to abandon our past experience and become someone completely different. Usually, the better move is to take stock of what we already know how to do and look for a new place where those skills are needed.
Here are three things you can do:
- Register for the ExperienceTO: Queen Street West Historical Tour that will take place on Saturday, December 12. Get your free ticket and meet us right outside Campbell House where our walk begins.
- Read the full story of Sir William Campbell in the Dictionary of Canadian Biography to see how his frontier legal training and political battles shaped early Upper Canada (now Ontario).
- Visit the Campbell House Museum to step inside the restored 1822 rooms and see how a 270-tonne brick home survived a 1.6-kilometre journey across downtown Toronto.
Thank you for taking the time to read and reflect.
Until next time,
Alex Rășcanu
P.S. If you'd like to read the past e-newsletters focused on life lessons, you can find them here.
P.P.S. See you at one of the upcoming monthly ExperienceTO historical tours, such as the Queen Street West one on Saturday, December 12.